Frequently Asked Questions

ALPRs collect license plate numbers and location data, plus the date and time the license plates were observed. Some systems capture the make and model of the vehicle or even information what people on the street or drivers look like. These systems can record thousands of license plates per minute. Time, location, and license plate data make it possible for law enforcement agencies to track an individual’s travel and even predict where a driver may be in the future based on their typical travel patterns.


California law says that ALPR data can’t be shared with federal agencies and that data can’t be retained for more than 60 days in most cases. This means it’s illegal for Elk Grove’s data to be shared with ICE, CBP, DEA or any other federal agency, other states’ law enforcement, or private companies.

We know that Flock is not complying with these laws.

According to California Senate Bill (SB) 34, the California Highway Patrol can “retain license plate data captured by license plate recognition (LPR) technology … for not more than 60 days unless the data is being used as evidence for the investigation of felonies.” SB 34 also requires agencies to disclose security breeches to any affected California resident.

Any agency that owns or licenses computerized data that includes personal information shall disclose any breach of the security of the system following discovery or notification of the breach in the security of the data to any resident of California whose unencrypted personal information was, or is reasonably believed to have been, acquired by an unauthorized person.

California SB 54, which went into effect on January 1, 2018, states that no state and local resources are used to assist federal immigration enforcement.

This bill would, among other things and subject to exceptions, prohibit state and local law enforcement agencies, including school police and security departments, from using money or personnel to investigate, interrogate, detain, detect, or arrest persons for immigration enforcement purposes, as specified, and would, subject to exceptions, proscribe other activities or conduct in connection with immigration enforcement by law enforcement agencies.

In 2023, California attorney general Rob Bonta confirmed that “SB 34 does not permit California LEAs to share ALPR information with private entities or out-of-state or federal agencies.” If Flock were following the law, audits would show that no California data appeared in searches by federal agencies or other states’ law enforcement. This is not the case.

Elk Grove PD states that it routinely conducts internal audits, but has otherwise dismissed concerns. In April 2026, the city council voted to expand Elk Grove’s use of Flock, despite multiple comments calling for an audit before committing to the expanded contract. Elk Grove PD has not released the results of these internal audits to the public.

Audits are our strongest tool in determining whether our data are secure. Technology reporters and privacy watchdogs also play a role in finding ways the Flock system is being exploited.

Based on our August 2026 community audit, we know that Elk Grove’s data have been shared with more than 3,600 organizations. Elk Grove PD performed around 260,000 out of the 8,300,000 searches. That is approximately 3% of searches. The remaining 97% of searches were by entities outside of Elk Grove (“external agencies”).

While Elk Grove PD’s own website says that it shares data with various other California police departments, including cities whose data have appeared in audits, it is clear from the audit that they have shared data much more widely than previously reported and than California law allows.

Elk Grove’s data have been shared with:

  • 290 California agencies that do not have data-sharing agreements or memoranda of understanding (MOUs) with Elk Grove.
  • The Northern California Regional Intelligence Center (NCRIC), a Fusion Center that includes collaboration with the Department of Homeland Security (DHS) and other federal agencies.
  • Riverside County Sheriff’s Office and Orange County Sherrif’s Office, agencies that have illegally shared with federal agencies.
  • El Cajon Police Department, a California agency that refuses to stop illegally sharing with out-of-state agencies.
  • Private corporations and other non-governmental organizations.
  • Unidentified organizations: more than 2,200 searches performed by entities with usernames such as “do not use,” “Org Name,” and “decommissioned org.”

Audits in other jurisdictions have found that Flock is not keeping data secure:

  • Multiple police departments have released “completely unredacted Flock audit logs,” which “in some cases include details on millions of Flock license plate searches made by thousands of police departments from around the country.”
  • A recent audit in Woodland found more than 3,000 out-of-state organizations directly accessed their Flock data. In addition, Woodland found that agencies searched their data more than 4,500 times with “immigration” as part of the search terms.
  • In Mountain View, an audit “showed that the first ALPR camera deployed had been set to a ‘nationwide’ setting by Flock Safety without MVPD’s permission or knowledge.” The ATF (Kentucky and Tennessee), Langley Air Force Base (Virginia), and the GSA Office of Inspector General had all accessed Mountain View’s data.
  • A Riverside County Sheriff’s Office audit showed that “law enforcement agencies across Southern California violated state law more than 100 times [in one] month”
  • U.S. Senator Ron Wyden (D-OR) publicly released findings from his investigation into Flock’s safety practices. The investigation indicated that data has been exposed to “hackers, foreign spies, and criminals,” and that at least 35 customer account passwords were stolen. That means we have no idea who may currently have access to Flock’s data.
  • Flock has left AI-powered cameras exposed to the internet, making them accessible to anyone. This is especially troubling because this variety of camera can focus on people on the street, not just license plates.

Law enforcement agencies search data recorded from Flock or other ALPRs without first getting a warrant. ALPRs form a passive system that does not require law enforcement to monitor it. ALPRs record the license plate and the time and date it passed a camera, whether or not there is a warrant for the driver or a legal justification for monitoring them. Some civil liberties groups have sued local governments, arguing that this particular form of constant surveillance without a warrant is a violation of the Fourth Amendment.

Flock and ALPRs do not stop or prevent crime. At best, they give law enforcement an additional tool to use when investigating crimes. In one city, crime increased after Flock cameras were installed.

In Atlanta, where Flock is headquartered, there are over 5,000 Flock cameras. However, research shows that rates of crime clearance (when someone is arrested for the crime or the crime is otherwise solved) have not improved, despite the immense number of Flock cameras watching the city. The Atlanta Community Press Collective reports that “Despite the eightfold growth of the integrated camera network between 2021 and 2026, APD’s clearance rate across eight major crime categories has remained relatively unchanged.” The presence of thousands of Flock ALPRs has not reduced crime in America’s most surveilled city, and it will not reduce crime in Elk Grove.

If Elk Grove wants to prevent crime, it can invest in proven solutions like increasing street lighting, affordable housing, dedicated bike lanes, community-building events, walkable neighborhoods, or youth programs. Designing a community that keeps people safe takes much more than posting cameras around town, it requires resources and sustained commitment.