Law-abiding Elk Grove, California residents’ movements are continuously tracked and recorded by local police – and shared in ways that appear to violate state law.

What’s Going On?

In Elk Grove, there are approximately 90 automated license plate readers (ALPRs), with cameras positioned all over town. The cameras, provided by a company called Flock Group Inc. (dba “Flock Safety”) record the license plate number, the vehicle’s make and model, dents and bumper stickers, and when and where the vehicle was seen. Flock records this information into a searchable nationwide database, whether or not the car is part of an active police investigation. Merely passing by one of these cameras is cause for your data to be recorded, and police search these records without a warrant.

DeFlock Elk Grove, a group of Elk Grove residents dedicated to removing ALPR mass surveillance from our community, recently conducted an audit of the City of Elk Grove’s (“the City”) use of the Flock system based on records from the City itself, that we obtained through Public Records Act requests.

What We Found

We were shocked to learn that only three percent of searches involving data recorded in Elk Grove were made by the Elk Grove Police Department (EGPD). The other 8 million results were searches from 3,600 other cities, counties, other states, federal agencies, and non-governmental organizations —including an entity that appears to be U.S. Customs and Border Protection (CBP). The contract the City has with Flock Safety is for more than $1.6 million dollars. Our tax dollars are funding a system that is primarily used to track us from outside Elk Grove.

California law (SB 34) only allows ALPR data to be shared with public agencies within the state of California. Yet, EGPD shared our data more than 1.3 million times with out-of-state, federal, and non-governmental entities. These searches can carry a penalty of $2,500 or more per search, if litigated.

It does not appear EGPD can control who is searching our data. EGPD told residents that certain agencies do not have access to our data, but these agencies were found to have searched Elk Grove’s ALPR records hundreds of thousands of times.

If Elk Grove’s ALPRs were being used exclusively to solve crimes in Elk Grove, we might expect EGPD to proudly explain that the searches they performed through the Flock system were all made in the course of active police investigations. Instead, in the records released to DeFlock Elk Grove, the EGPD had redacted the reasons for every single search, providing no accountability or transparency to residents.

We were able to match some Elk Grove search IDs to Flock records from the City of Woodland and discovered that EGPD and other entities used immigration enforcement, immigration agency assistance, and federal agency assistance as reasons for searches in Elk Grove, in apparent violation of an additional California law (SB 54).

Does it Really Matter?

People may say they have “nothing to hide,” and being surveilled does not matter to them because they are not breaking the law. Still, what is worth hiding can change.In 2022, a Supreme Court decision ended a half-century of legal abortion by overturning Roe v. Wade. Overnight, abortion became illegal in the 13 states with “trigger laws” that were waiting for the Supreme Court’s ruling. On June 24, 2022, people seeking abortions had “nothing to hide,” but on June 25, essential reproductive care was now a crime.

In fact, in May of last year, the Johnson County Sheriff’s Office in Texas conducted a nationwide search of the Flock ALPR network “to look for a woman who self-administered an abortion” as part of an investigation “into the death of the fetus” to determine “whether they could charge the woman with a crime.”

The Bottom Line

We should have the right to live free of constant surveillance. Yet, it is nearly impossible to move through the world having our movements mapped by these ALPR systems. There are currently at least 121,000 ALPR cameras in the United States.

Surveillance is not safety. Giving agencies, from the local police to the federal government, access to information about the movements of people all over America grants them far too much power. That is why DeFlock Elk Grove is calling on the city to end its contract with Flock Safety and its use of ALPRs altogether.

We live in a lovely city, but the 90 cameras that feed into a national surveillance network are not what makes Elk Grove a wonderful place to live. Surveillance cannot make us safe—if it did, we would live in a utopia by now. Only we keep us safe, through our commitment to the community and the people in it.

Learn More and Take Action

Click here for a summary of ALL key audit findings.

Click here to tell our elected officials your thoughts.

Leave a Comment